Probably a Game

The Totemist on Steam

Rose: For someone who has never heard of your game, how would you describe it without using the usual genre labels?

I would describe The Totemist as “A story-first occult shop sim that has relatable characters with real problems and real flaws. There’s also a frog assistant that loves wearing hats and never blinks.”

Rose: Where did the idea for this game come from?

There are a lot of answers to this question, but I think the most literal answer is my wife. I wanted to make a project she would like, so I just asked her directly what she would like to play. Her answer was actually a crystal shop simulator, which The Totemist did start off as. Things deviated when I started talking to her about the fact that I wanted crafting to play a role, and I didn’t want to just cut gems into different shapes or something. So I asked her what she might make out of them.
This ended up turning into an ongoing conversation about modern witchcraft practices, rituals, charms, and the like. She’s also a big reader, so she had a lot of good reference material right on her bookshelf for me when I was researching concepts.
When I got past the foundational research, I really wanted to make the game meaningful through its story and relatable through its characters.
So that’s where the real work began, and why the game is so story-driven.

Rose: What makes your game different from other games in the same space?

The Totemist offers a very rich story experience. I think a lot of shop sims are really more focused on that crunchy day-to-day economy and incrementally getting rich. There is some of that in The Totemist. I definitely went overboard with the crafting combinations on the lore side of things as well.
Every combination of crafted items and rituals produces a new piece of lore specific to that combination. It also has some mechanical changes, too, but that’s maybe less interesting in this context.
This is actually my first full-length, commercially released game, so I think my inexperience contributed to some unique, if slightly janky, approaches.

Rose: Was there anything you had to cut that you still secretly wish you could put back?

That’s a good question! There’s a lot of stuff that didn’t make the cut in the first place that I wish I’d had the bandwidth to do, but not much stuff got cut after I added it because I was (overly) cautious with scope creep.
One thing that didn’t happen, but was in my original concept, was that you would actually get to travel to each gathering area and gather your supplies. In my mind, I was like, “It would be so cool to change perspectives and have top-down exploration and minigames where you mine, scavenge, dig, or even farm herbs.” I scrapped that idea entirely before I even built the gathering system. Truthfully, I don’t wish I could put it in the game now that the game is fleshed out. It would have been a total clash of vibes, but I like it as a theoretical concept that still floats around my brain.

Rose: What is something players probably won't realize took an absurd amount of work?

The item descriptions. I’ve watched a lot of streamers play this game, and aside from the initial base item descriptions early in the game, they don’t read the item lore pretty much ever. Fair, honestly.
But there are one hundred and forty-four unique item descriptions.
Every single one is specific to the combination of crafted item and ritual, giving the creation a new name and lore that reflects its properties and the ritual and/or charm used.
To expand on this, the rituals are based on actual rituals in modern witchcraft, as are the totems and talismans. All of the properties attached to them are based on my research into their real-life counterparts. Sage is cleansing and calming, for example, so any recipe containing sage would inherit those properties alongside those of the
other materials.
From there, I considered the practical uses of the totem and ritual, and concocted a little description that reflected the resulting item.For example, a rabbit's foot + Dream Softening (sage-based) produces "Dreamwalker's Luck," with the description: "The clover's gone drowsy and the luck comes softer now. Less lightning strike, more gentle current, steering you right while you sleep."
Frankly, I had fun doing this, but it was an incredible time sink that might not matter to 99% of players. That said, I’d do it again in a heartbeat.

Rose: What is the weirdest bug you've encountered that you almost wanted to keep?

I don’t think I had any fun bugs, if I’m being honest. I mean, Tully was doing weird stuff when I was first developing the problem-assist system and inventory management, but it was mostly things like items getting fired into odd places or bouncing where they shouldn’t. So now the cat’s out of the bag: The Totemist had strictly frustrating bugs. Luckily, Tully has eaten all of them, to my knowledge.

Rose: Is there a particular emotion you wanted players to walk away with from your game?

I think if I had to pick just one, it would be that the player just feels seen.
I guess “seen” isn’t a typical emotional category, but I didn’t design the game to dictate to players how they should feel. My goal was to make a story with characters who were just relatable, at least in moments, in specific lines, or in specific actions they take. I’ve mentioned this in previous comments and interviews, but there are pieces of all of these characters that represent the strengths of my wife, and issues I’ve struggled with. I thought it was a good way to represent, metaphorically, the way she balances me. In that, there are definitely some raw nerves that I exposed. Nothing that I explicitly state at any point, but just vulnerable, deeply human pieces of myself.

Rose: What's one piece of advice you wish you'd had before starting?

Don’t doubt your ability to learn new things in the pursuit of creation.

Rose: Five years from now, what do you hope people remember about this game?

If the game stuck with them for any reason for 5+ years, that would be a win for me regardless of the specifics. That said, it would make me smile to know someone fondly remembered the feeling they had when they were introduced to any particular character. If they felt like they related deeply to any of them, enough to think about it years later, that would be just amazing.

Rose: Why should someone reading/watching this go play your game today?

To relax, to take some time to read, and to feel connected. Above all, to see a frog wear hats.

Rose: Finally, the question we ask every developer: After everything you’ve told us, can you officially confirm that your game is, in fact, probably a game? Why should we believe you?

I can confirm that The Totemist is probably a game. You should believe me because I’m probably an indie game developer. If you Google Steam, you will probably find that it’s a platform for PC games, and if you type “The Totemist” into the search bar, you will probably find my game, with a stunning and lore-accurate illustration of Tully, who is probably the best frog shop assistant a modern witch has ever had.